SUMMARY
I finally finished the Billy Wilder book I mentioned in the Double
Indemnity review and have since moved on to Scott Eyman's book
on director John Ford titled "Print the Legend". Over
the next few months I plan on reviewing some of the John Ford
films available on DVD. (Stagecoach, The Searchers, They Were
Expendable, etc.)
How Green Was My Valley is John Ford's academy award winning picture
from 1941 and one of the most beautifully crafted Hollywood pictures
of its time. How Green Was My Valley is set in a coal town in
Ireland in the late 1800's and is about family, and the mythical
status the concept of the perfect family holds for most people.
What this film expresses so poetically is that the perfect family
is impossible to hold together. Children grow up and develop their
own opinions. Some die young and others leave to go to far off
countries. Through the eyes of Huw Morgan (Roddy McDowall) we
see his family just as it is about to break apart. In my opinion
this picture is perfect in every aspect. From the acting, writing,
set design, music, cinematography, and most importantly
in the direction of John Ford. This is a film not to be missed.
The
technical quality of this DVD is outstanding. The print the transfer
was made from is very well preserved for a film from the early
forties. The transfer is as good as I have seen from a film made
during this era. Typically the transfers for these films will
have somewhat washed out blacks. The blacks are so deep in this
transfer I cannot imagine that it looked a whole lot better when
this film originally hit the big screen. I hope when Fox gets
around to Ford's The Grapes of Wrath they take the same care in
producing a quality product. The one area this disc does suffer
is in its extras. A film of this stature deserves more than just
a theatrical trailer.
|